DynamoDB vs Redis: Choosing Between a NoSQL Database and In-Memory Cache

Selecting the right data storage solution is crucial for application performance, scalability, and cost-effectiveness. Amazon DynamoDB and Redis are two popular options that often come up in this conversation, but they serve fundamentally different purposes.

In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll explore the differences between DynamoDB (a persistent NoSQL database) and Redis (an in-memory data store), helping you understand when to use each and how they can work together.

Technology Overview: DynamoDB vs Redis

Feature	Amazon DynamoDB	Redis
Type	Fully managed NoSQL database	In-memory data structure store
Primary Use	Persistent data storage	Caching, real-time data structures
Data Location	Persistent storage (SSDs)	Primary in memory (with optional persistence)
Latency	Single-digit milliseconds	Microseconds
Data Size	Virtually unlimited	Limited by available memory
AWS Service	Native DynamoDB	ElastiCache for Redis
Data Structures	Key-value, documents	Strings, lists, sets, sorted sets, hashes, streams

Understanding the Fundamental Difference

Before diving deeper, it’s important to understand that DynamoDB and Redis are designed for different primary purposes:

DynamoDB is a fully managed, serverless NoSQL database designed to be your application’s persistent data store, providing durable storage with consistent performance at any scale.
Redis is an in-memory data structure store often used as a cache, message broker, or for real-time data processing where ultra-low latency is critical. While Redis can persist data to disk, it’s primarily designed for data that fits in memory.

This fundamental difference drives many of the design choices and trade-offs in each system.

Performance Comparison

DynamoDB Performance

DynamoDB delivers consistent, single-digit millisecond response times at virtually any scale. Key performance characteristics include:

Latency typically ranges from 1-10ms for point operations
Automatic partitioning for horizontal scaling
Throughput limited by provisioned capacity or on-demand limits
Performance consistent regardless of data size
Optimized for key-based access patterns

While DynamoDB is extremely fast for a database, it is nonetheless bound by the laws of physics: data must be retrieved from storage (albeit very fast SSD storage).

Redis Performance

Redis operates primarily in memory, providing:

Microsecond latency (typically 100-500μs)
Up to 100x faster than DynamoDB for certain operations
Extremely high throughput for simple operations
Performance degrades if dataset exceeds available memory
Support for complex operations like set intersections in memory

Redis achieves this exceptional performance by keeping all data in RAM, making it ideal for use cases where absolute minimum latency is required.

Data Model & Capabilities

Dynomate: Modern DynamoDB GUI Client

Built for real developer workflows with AWS profile integration, multi-session support, and team collaboration.

AWS SSO support & multi-region browsing

Script-like operations with data chaining

Git-friendly local storage for team sharing

Download Free Trial Compare GUI Clients

No account needed. Install and start using immediately.

Table browsing across regions
Flexible query & scan interface
AWS API logging & debugging

DynamoDB Data Model

DynamoDB uses a key-value and document data model:

Each item has a primary key (partition key and optional sort key)
Items can store attributes (similar to JSON)
Maximum item size of 400KB
Limited query capabilities (primarily key-based access)
Secondary indexes for additional access patterns
Transactions across multiple items

Redis Data Model

Redis offers a rich set of data structures:

Simple key-value storage (strings)
Lists for queues and stacks
Sets and sorted sets for unique collections and rankings
Hashes for field-value pairs
Bit arrays for space-efficient boolean operations
HyperLogLog for counting unique items
Streams for append-only log data
Geospatial indexes for location data

These specialized data structures enable Redis to efficiently solve problems that would be more complex with DynamoDB’s simpler model.

Use Cases: When to Choose Each

When to Use DynamoDB

DynamoDB is the right choice when you need:

Persistent primary database: For storing critical application data that must be durable and survive restarts
Large datasets: When your data exceeds available memory or grows unpredictably
Automatic scaling: For applications with variable traffic without capacity planning
ACID transactions: When you need atomic operations across multiple items
Long-term data storage: For data that needs to be retained indefinitely
Serverless architectures: When paired with AWS Lambda and other serverless services

Common DynamoDB use cases include:

User profiles and account data
Product catalogs
Game state and player data
Session management (where persistence is required)
Order history and transaction records
IoT device data

When to Use Redis

Redis excels when you need:

Ultra-low latency: When microsecond response times matter
Caching layer: To reduce database load and speed up responses
Specialized data structures: For leaderboards, counters, pub/sub, etc.
Real-time analytics: For fast-changing metrics and calculations
Rate limiting: To control API usage with precise timing
Message broker: For lightweight messaging between services

Common Redis use cases include:

Caching database query results
Session storage (where ultra-fast access is prioritized over persistence)
Real-time leaderboards and counting
Queues and job management
Rate limiting and request throttling
Real-time analytics dashboards

Persistence & Durability

DynamoDB Durability

DynamoDB is designed for durability:

Data automatically replicated across multiple AZs
Synchronous writes for durability
Point-in-time recovery (PITR) for backups
No data loss on server failures
11 9’s of durability (99.999999999%)

Redis Persistence Options

Redis is primarily in-memory but offers persistence options:

RDB snapshots (point-in-time snapshots to disk)
AOF logs (append-only file logging all write operations)
Hybrid approaches (combining snapshots and logs)
ElastiCache Multi-AZ with automatic failover

Even with these options, Redis is typically not used as a system of record for critical data, as its persistence is a secondary feature rather than its primary design goal.

Scaling & Operational Considerations

DynamoDB Scaling

DynamoDB scaling is fully managed:

Automatic partitioning as data grows
No capacity planning required with on-demand mode
No operational overhead for scaling
Global tables for multi-region deployment
Storage scaled automatically

Redis Scaling

Redis scaling requires more consideration:

Vertical scaling by increasing instance size
Cluster mode for horizontal scaling (with resharding)
Read replicas for read scaling
Memory is the primary limiting factor
Requires explicit capacity planning

ElastiCache for Redis reduces some operational burden, but scaling Redis still requires more planning than DynamoDB.

Cost Considerations

DynamoDB Pricing

DynamoDB pricing is based on:

Provisioned capacity (RCUs/WCUs) or on-demand requests
Storage used
Optional features (PITR, global tables)
Data transfer

DynamoDB can scale down to very low costs for infrequently accessed data or even to zero with the free tier.

Redis Pricing

Redis (using ElastiCache) pricing is based on:

Node instance types and hours
Multi-AZ replication
Backup storage
Data transfer

Redis always has a baseline cost for running instances, even during idle periods, making it potentially more expensive for low-volume workloads.

The Hybrid Approach: Using DynamoDB and Redis Together

Familiar with these Dynamodb Challenges ?

Writing one‑off scripts for simple DynamoDB operations
Constantly switching between AWS profiles and regions
Sharing and managing database operations with your team

You should try Dynomate GUI Client for DynamoDB

Create collections of operations that work together like scripts
Seamless integration with AWS SSO and profile switching
Local‑first design with Git‑friendly sharing for team collaboration

Download Free Trial Compare GUI Clients

One of the most powerful strategies is combining DynamoDB and Redis, leveraging the strengths of each:

DynamoDB as primary datastore: Store your application’s persistent data in DynamoDB
Redis as a caching layer: Cache frequently accessed DynamoDB data in Redis
Redis for real-time operations: Use Redis for leaderboards, counters, and other real-time features
DynamoDB for durability: Periodically persist critical Redis data to DynamoDB for backup

This approach can dramatically improve performance while maintaining data durability:

Reduce DynamoDB costs by lowering read requests
Achieve microsecond latency for cached data
Maintain durability for important information
Support specialized data structures when needed

Example hybrid architecture:

Store user profiles in DynamoDB
Cache active user profiles in Redis
Implement real-time leaderboards in Redis
Periodically save leaderboard snapshots to DynamoDB

Migration Considerations

When migrating between these technologies:

From Redis to DynamoDB:

Consider how to model Redis data structures in DynamoDB
Plan for potentially higher latency
Design access patterns around DynamoDB’s key-based model
Consider DAX if caching is still needed

From DynamoDB to Redis:

Ensure data fits in memory
Develop persistence strategy for critical data
Plan for scaling as data grows
Consider which Redis data structures best match your needs

Monitoring and Optimization

DynamoDB Monitoring

CloudWatch metrics for capacity, throttling, and latency
Cost Explorer for usage analysis
Use auto-scaling to automatically adjust capacity

Redis Monitoring

Memory usage and eviction rates
Connection counts
CPU utilization
Cache hit rates

Tools like Dynomate can help visualize and manage your DynamoDB data more effectively, while specialized Redis monitoring tools can provide insights into cache performance.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice

Switching from Dynobase? Try Dynomate

Developers are switching to Dynomate for these key advantages:

Better Multi-Profile Support

Native AWS SSO integration
Seamless profile switching
Multiple accounts in a single view

Developer-Focused Workflow

Script-like operation collections
Chain data between operations
Full AWS API logging for debugging

Team Collaboration

Git-friendly collection sharing
No account required for installation
Local-first data storage for privacy

Privacy & Security

No account creation required
100% local data storage
No telemetry or usage tracking

Try Dynomate Free for 7 Days Dynomate vs. Dynobase

The choice between DynamoDB and Redis isn’t about which is better in absolute terms, but rather which better serves your specific needs:

Use DynamoDB when you need a durable, scalable database with consistent performance for your application’s persistent data.
Use Redis when you need microsecond latency, specialized data structures, or an effective caching layer.
Use both together to create a highly performant, scalable, and durable data architecture.

By understanding the strengths and limitations of each technology, you can make informed decisions that balance performance, cost, and operational complexity for your unique requirements.

Remember that both technologies excel in their respective domains, and the most effective architectures often leverage both for maximum benefit.

Ready to start working with DynamoDB more efficiently? Check out Dynomate, our professional GUI client that makes working with DynamoDB data and performance optimization significantly easier.